Anthropic의 국방부와의 논의에 대한 Dario Amodei의 성명

출처: Hacker News — https://www.anthropic.com/news/statement-department-of-war

• AI의 중요성: Anthropic은 AI를 통해 미국과 민주주의를 방어하고자 하며, 국방부 및 정보 기관에 모델을 배포.
• 국가 안보 기여: 미국 정부의 기밀 네트워크와 국립 연구소에 모델을 최초로 배포.
• 제한된 사용 사례: 대규모 국내 감시와 완전 자율 무기의 사용은 민주적 가치를 훼손할 수 있다고 보고, 이를 제한.
• 국방부와의 갈등: 국방부는 모든 합법적 사용을 요구하며, Anthropic의 제한을 철회하지 않을 경우 계약 해지 위협.
• 협력 의지: Anthropic은 국방부와의 협력을 지속하고자 하며, 제한을 유지한 채로 기술을 제공할 의향.

의견

댓글/토론에서 나온 의견을 참고용으로 정리했습니다. (사실로 단정하지 말고 맥락 확인 권장)

• Hacker News · @brooke2k: The constant reference to "democracy" as the thing that makes us good and them bad is so frustrating to me because we are barely a democracy. We are ruled by a two-party state. Nobody else has any power or any chance at power. How is that really much better than a one-party state? Actually, these two parties are so …
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47174106
• Hacker News · @ponorin: As a non-American they've lost me already at the first sentence. United States, even before Trump, has always been about projecting power rather than spreading democracy. There are several non-Western, former colonies who does democracy better than the US. Despite democratic backsliding being a worldwide phenomen…
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47179920
• Hacker News · @alephnerd: One piece of context that everyone should keep in mind with the recent Anthropic showdown - Anthropic is trying to land British [0], Indian [1], Japanese [2], and German [3] public sector contracts. Working with the DoD/DoW on offensive usecases would put these contracts at risk, because Anthropic most likely isn…
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47174239
• Hacker News · @fnordpiglet: I find the fact they used the vanity name “Department of War” and “Secretary of War” sad given Congress has not changed the name and the president doesn’t get to decide the naming of statutory departments or secretary level roles. Maybe it’s just an appeasement to the thin skinned people who need powder rooms and are …
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47176763
• Hacker News · @cmrdporcupine: I'm glad to see this as the top comment. I was, until recently, a loyal Anthropic customer. No more. Because the way non-Americans are spoken of by a company that serves an international market (and this isn't the first instance): "Mass domestic surveillance. We support the use of AI for lawful foreign intel…
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47173898
• Hacker News · @u1hcw9nx: Google, OpenAI Employees Voice Support for Anthropic in Open Letter. We Will Not Be Divided https://notdivided.org/ ----- The Department of War is threatening to - Invoke the Defense Production Act to force Anthropic to serve their model to the military and "tailor its model to the military's needs…
  • 링크: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47178662

댓글

댓글을 읽어오는 중입니다.